T O P

My Nintendo Game Tier List

My Nintendo Game Tier List

dukeofnes

This seems like such a random assortment of Nintendo games (also Minecraft?). How did you pick the games on this list?


notnamedjoebutsteve

The list said it was based on all games that were on a Nintendo console. (If you look close at Minecraft it says Wii U and Nintendo Switch.) And I didn’t add the games Ive never played.


RedDustCant

I don't know how you placed 3D All-stars in there or why but it's seemingly redundant due to all three games already existing in vastly different grades from one another.


The_Metroid

Aww, no Metroid?


inumnoback

You have a vendetta against Mario party


Minibotas

Who doesn’t


tlacct

Mario RPG is a masterpiece to me though. “A” rank for sure in my mind.


[deleted]

[удалено]


notnamedjoebutsteve

[Here!](https://tiermaker.com/create/the-nintendo-tier-list-for-the-ages-604673)


trashyyee

Why wild world so low down :(((


notnamedjoebutsteve

My least favorite out of all the mainline AC games.


Weim924

Nice list! Gotta have Super Mario 3 in the top tier tho.


GenericUser_____

Yes yes yes yes! Earthbound and Mother 3! Wooo! Metroid should be atleast on the list though man


Mostyion

what about Xenoblade, Pikmin, Fire Emblem, and Metroid?


notnamedjoebutsteve

Games I’ve never played, tho I really wanna play Xneoblade. I’m quite big of an RPG guy


Mostyion

Yeah, Xenoblade and the Xeno series is really good.


Ryanizawsum

Mario Party 8 fans rise up


TheT0T1

The Wii was the perfect console for Mario Party and MP8 is the one that didn't fuck it up


Partyharry

That's not George of the Jungle 2.


SlightlyEnragedOwl

NSMBW in S, Respect.


AWSUMSAS

Where the hell is Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door? I was gonna say bold move putting Super Paper Mario as the best in the series (though I do agree with that choice) but I can't even find TTYD anywhere on here.


notnamedjoebutsteve

I’ve never actually played TTYD, I’ve seen many videos, but I don’t think it’s fair to judge a game just on what you’ve watched.


edhh2005

How dare you put earthbound beginnings so low


sparkypagano

Maybe this is my nostalgia speaking but Mario sunshine is criminally low


kg1479

Agreed.


Dragozan

But where's Corey in the House on Nintendo DS?


notnamedjoebutsteve

I had to crop the tier list because I put the game so high.


Dragozan

Understandable. Thanks for clarifying


Inspirational_Lizard

Out of curiosity, what the fuck is up with miitoptia? Why do people think it is good? To me, it seems like a lazy 1st party shovelware game, with its only selling point in ads being: look it's funny. Yet all the "jokes" are dogshit jokes you would hear in a 3rd grade classroom.


AceZackary

if they find it enjoyable, they put it high


Inspirational_Lizard

Well thats obvious, I just can't understand why.


LtCmdrData87

I think most people (including myself) like it for one major reason: the character creation. The fact that you are able to travel a world with the Medic from TF2, Thomas Jefferson, and Scott the Woz against a rubber chicken masquerading as a Dark Lord is more than enough for a lot of people.


Inspirational_Lizard

Yeah, that is pretty awesome, but a better mii maker really wouldn't sell the whole game for me y'know?


LtCmdrData87

That's alright.


Loazy131

Yes, yes, YES! Sticker Star is the most underrated Paper Mario game to ever exist!


Person-UwU

Super Luigi U below Super Mario Bros hurts me


champion_urbosa

earthbound and mother 3!!! we love to see it!!!


LEDAfterBurners

you rly put earthbound above mother 3


SethBozo

How many of these have you played?


notnamedjoebutsteve

All of them.


Minibotas

Ah yes my favourite Nintendo game: *Minecraft*


not_named_lucas

Not only is Minecraft on this Nintendo game tier list, but it is also on both A and B tier


notnamedjoebutsteve

Well that’s the Wii U and Switch versions. Which are both in B and A tier respectively


ImPickleRickFunny

I dispise top 2000 not because of the quality of the game (it is bad) but because of the expectations I had for a Mario party compilation game


Over_Case

How is LM:DM in C tier list???!?!? It's so good!😆


Loch32

Putting London 2012 in c is a low blow. That's one of my favourite wii games, if not Nintendo games


therollingdivision

DKC 2 and Wild World should be higher up


Nukatha

Earthbound Beginnings is better than Earthbound. Sorry for your confusion.


Cianmc6

*it’s just their opinion, it’s just their opinion, it’s just their opinion...* **MARIO PAINT DESERVES S TIER!!!!!!**


AWSUMSAS

Are you really gonna sit there and say that Mario Party 10 is better than Mario Party 9 in any way, shape or form


notnamedjoebutsteve

Bowser Party.


AWSUMSAS

Bowser Party might as well be singleplayer.


CheezeSteak701

What about Splatoon?


notnamedjoebutsteve

Never played unfortunately, and it’s genre is not something I’m into


CheezeSteak701

I know this is late, but it's actually really unique compared to other shooters. The gameplay is fun, the lore is super deep, and I would definitely recommend it


ProjektSavi

Super Paper Mario in S tier, respect. I love that story


EnderJackson

I loved playing Mario Party the Top 100


Noldster

Link to the Past in C tier makes me a sad panda.


Luigisopa

Imagine Miitopia and Mario 64 on the same tier.


this_is_a_mini_acc77

Finally somebody acknowledges the beauty of nsmbwii


wafflegism

Not a big pokemon/smash fan are we? :p


egp12995

He put Smash Ultimate, Brawl and 64 in the A and S tier. Half of the games being top tier sounds like a fan of to me.